Shareholder exclusion clause in France: validity and process
Shareholder exclusion clause: validity, drafting and implementation
Share this article

A retenir

  • In an SAS, the exclusion clause is provided for in Article L. 227-16 of the Commercial Code. It may be adopted by the majority specified in the articles of association.
  • In a limited liability company (SARL) with fixed capital, there is no provision for this in the law: this must be supplemented by a shareholders’ agreement.
  • The member concerned must be allowed to vote on their own exclusion.
  • The value of the shares is determined in accordance with the articles of association or, failing that, by an expert.

Your partner is no longer honouring their commitments. They are competing with the company, blocking decisions or have simply gone off the grid. You are looking for a way out, but the law protects their right to remain a partner. The exclusion clause is often the only pre-arranged way out. However, it must be valid, well-drafted and applied without any missteps.

A procedural error can be enough to have an exclusion set aside. Here is what the law and the Court of Cassation say, step by step. If the dispute has already arisen, a solicitor specialising in disputes between partners can help you choose the right strategy.

What is an exclusion clause?

An exclusion clause is a provision in the articles of association. It obliges a partner to transfer their shares, on grounds and in accordance with a procedure laid down in advance. It is a forced exit, but one that is regulated.

Without a legal or statutory basis, no one can force a partner to leave. The exclusion clause provides this basis. It applies to a partner’s shares in a limited liability company ( SARL ) or their shares in a simplified joint-stock company (SAS).

Think of it as an emergency exit. It is planned in advance, as part of the building’s layout, not during a fire. Once a conflict has arisen, it often becomes impossible to secure the necessary votes to add it.

Do not confuse the exclusion clause with other mechanisms

Several tools have a similar effect, but operate under different rules.

Mechanism Source What triggers the exit
Exclusion clause Articles of Association The company
Approval clause Articles of Association The company in relation to a third-party purchaser
Letter of intent to sell (good or bad leaver) Shareholders’ agreement The beneficiary of the promise
Withdrawal Statute or articles of association The shareholder themselves

Nor should this be confused with the exclusive liability clause in a contract, which falls under contract law.

A partnership agreement may suffice, without an exclusion clause. The judge presiding over interim relief proceedings in Paris upheld this in a case handled by the firm (16 October 2026). He ordered a transfer of shares based on a call option contained in the agreement.

For forced exits without an exclusion clause, see our guide on forcing a partner to sell his shares.

In which types of companies is the exclusion clause valid?

The law provides for the exclusion clause in the case of SAS companies, under Article L. 227-16 of the Commercial Code. Companies with variable capital also permit it. In SARLs with fixed capital, it remains vulnerable without a shareholders’ agreement.

Exclusion in an SAS: a mechanism provided for by the Commercial Code

The articles of association of an SAS may stipulate that a shareholder will be required to sell their shares. The articles themselves set out the conditions for this compulsory sale. They may also suspend the shareholder’s non-financial rights until the sale takes place.

Act No. 2019-744 of 19 July 2019 changed the situation. Previously, adopting or amending an exclusion clause required unanimity. Now, a collective decision is sufficient, subject to the conditions laid down in the articles of association (Article L. 227-19 of the Commercial Code).

The Court of Cassation applies this rule to SASs established before 2019 (Cass. com., 12 October 2022, No. 22-40.013). The Constitutional Council subsequently ruled that this provision was in accordance with the Constitution (Decision No. 2022-1029 QPC of 9 December 2022).

Key point: In an SAS, a majority can now include an exclusion clause in the articles of association. A minority shareholder may therefore be subject to a rule they have never voted for. Read every draft amendment to the articles of association before the general meeting.

Exclusion in SARLs and civil companies: key points

In companies with variable capital and civil companies, the Court of Cassation applies the exclusion clause. In limited liability companies (SARLs) with a fixed share capital, no legislation provides for this: on its own, it is not sufficient to ensure an exit.

In companies with variable share capital, Article L. 231-6 of the Commercial Code authorises exclusion. The Court of Cassation has even upheld a clause providing for exclusion ‘on just grounds’, without a list of specific grounds (Cass. com., 9 November 2022, No. 21-10.540).

In a civil partnership, the Court of Cassation also applies the exclusion clauses provided for in the articles of association (Cass. com., 20 March 2012, No. 11-10.855).

In limited liability companies (SARLs) with fixed capital, the situation is different. The Commercial Code does not provide for exclusion, and the Court of Cassation has not ruled on the matter. One Court of Appeal has upheld it (Versailles Court of Appeal, 18 November 2025, No. 24/06500), but other analyses consider it to be without effect.

Our advice is therefore straightforward: in an SARL, do not rely solely on the exclusion clause. Supplement it with a shareholders’ agreement containing undertakings to sell. This commitment to sell, signed by each shareholder, is not subject to this debate.

Company form Legal basis Level of security
SAS Article L. 227-16 of the Commercial Code High, provided the procedure is followed
Company with variable capital Article L. 231-6 of the Commercial Code High, case law from 2022
Civil partnership Case law of the Court of Cassation Case law, clauses applied by the judge
Limited liability company with fixed capital No legislation, no ruling by the Court of Cassation Weak: should be supplemented by a shareholders’ agreement

Add an exclusion clause whilst the company is in operation

In a simplified joint-stock company (SAS), a collective decision taken in accordance with the articles of association is sufficient. Elsewhere, caution is advised. Article 1836 of the Civil Code prohibits increasing a shareholder’s liabilities without their consent. Some case law infer from this that a clause added whilst the company is in existence requires unanimity.

How should an effective exclusion clause be drafted?

An effective clause specifies four elements: the grounds, the decision-making body, the procedure and the calculation of the price. Any ambiguity in these areas provides grounds for the excluded partner to challenge the decision in court.

Grounds for exclusion

The grounds must be objective and verifiable. Here are some common examples:

  • serious misconduct or repeated breaches of the articles of association;
  • breach of a non-competition clause or poaching of customers by a partner;
  • the poaching of employees for the benefit of a competing company;
  • the removal of a director from office;
  • the termination of the employed partner’s employment contract;
  • a change of control of a corporate partner, a provision which always requires unanimity in a simplified joint-stock company (SAS);
  • a prolonged absence from the business, for example where a partner no longer comes to work.

The competent body and the procedure

The articles of association specify who is authorised to order the exclusion. This is often the body of shareholders, acting by a qualified majority.

A dedicated body may also take the decision, such as a committee or a board of directors. The clause then sets out the procedure for notifying the grounds for exclusion, the time limit for the shareholder to defend themselves and the hearing of the shareholder.

The buy-out price of the shares

In an SAS, the articles of association set out the terms of the sale price. Failing that, the price is determined by agreement between the parties. Otherwise, an expert determines it in accordance with Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code, to which Article L. 227-18 of the Commercial Code refers.

The expert is chosen by the parties. In the absence of agreement, the president of the court appoints the expert, in accordance with the expedited procedure on the merits and without right of appeal. Since the Order of 31 July 2014, the expert must apply the valuation rules agreed by the parties.

Key point: Specify a method for calculating the price, not a fixed amount. A clear formula limits disputes; for example, the revalued net asset value. The expert is then bound by this formula.

Example of an exclusion clause (commented template)

Here is a simplified, fictitious example of such a clause. It illustrates the expected structure but must be adapted to each company.

Article X: Expulsion

  1. Grounds. Any partner who breaches the non-competition clause or commits a serious offence prejudicial to the company may be excluded.
  2. Notice. The chairman shall notify the partner of the allegations by registered letter, at least fifteen days before the decision is taken.
  3. Defence. The partner shall submit their observations, in writing or orally, before the vote.
  4. Decision. The partners shall decide by a two-thirds majority. The partner concerned shall take part in the vote.
  5. Valuation. The valuation shall be carried out in accordance with the method set out in Schedule 2. In the absence of agreement, Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code shall apply.

Do your articles of association date from the company’s incorporation?

Goldwin Avocats, in Paris’s 16th arrondissement, will review your exclusion clause and update it.


REQUEST AN AUDIT

 

How can you carry out an exclusion without the risk of it being overturned?

Follow the procedure laid down in the articles of association to the letter. Notify the partner of the allegations, allow them time to respond, summon them to a meeting and allow them to vote. Then have the transfer recorded and the price set.

The stages of the exclusion procedure

  1. Review the articles of association and the shareholders’ agreement: grounds, governing body, majority required, time limits.
  2. Compile the case file, including evidence dated to support the alleged breaches.
  3. Notify the partner of the allegations in the prescribed manner.
  4. Arrange a hearing before any decision is taken.
  5. Convenethe general meeting with a specific agenda.
  6. Vote on the expulsion, with the member concerned present.
  7. Appoint the purchaser and set the price, either by mutual agreement or through an expert.

The firm secured a ruling to this effect. The Nanterre Commercial Court upheldthe expulsion of a partner from an SAS. It verified each statutory step before dismissing the application for annulment (24 June 2026, Case No. 2025F01686).

The voting rights of the excluded shareholder

The partner concerned always votes on their own exclusion. This is a fundamental right: every partner participates in collective decisions (Article 1844 of the Civil Code). The articles of association of an SAS cannot deprive them of this right.

The Court of Cassation reiterated this on 29 May 2024. If the articles of association deprive the shareholder of this right to vote, that provision is disregarded. The remainder of the exclusion clause continues to apply.

Please note: the articles of association may suspend a shareholder’s non-financial rights, such as the right to vote, but only after the decision to exclude them has been taken. This suspension lasts until their shares are sold.

Key point: The shareholder you wish to exclude must be able to vote on their own exclusion. A clause that deprives them of this right is deemed null and void on this point. A decision taken without their vote is liable to be set aside.

The principle of the right to be heard

Before being expelled, the shareholder must be given the opportunity to defend themselves. They must be made aware of the allegations against them and be able to explain themselves before the vote. This is the principle of the right to be heard, which the courts require of all organisations.

However, the court cannot require more than is stipulated in the articles of association. If the clause merely requires the grounds to be stated, that is sufficient. The Court of Cassation reiterated this in February 2025.

Are you preparing to expel a member?

Our solicitors ensure that the notice of meeting, the statement of grounds for exclusion and the minutes are in order.


LET’S DISCUSS YOUR CASE

 

Expelled partner: what remedies are available to challenge the decision?

The expelled partner may seek the annulment of the decision, damages or a revaluation of their shares. Their chances of success depend on whether the procedure was conducted properly and whether the grounds for expulsion are valid.

Grounds for challenging the decision

  • the absence of a legal or statutory basis, particularly in limited liability companies (SARLs) with fixed capital;
  • deprivation of the right to vote on one’s own expulsion;
  • failure to comply with the procedure laid down in the articles of association, if the articles of association of a simplified joint-stock company (SAS) provide for nullity in such cases;
  • grievances not having been notified or a non-existent ground;
  • an abuse of majority power, where the expulsion serves solely the interests of the majority shareholders.

What changed on 1 October 2025

Since 1 October 2025, it has become more difficult to have an expulsion set aside. A reform now imposes three conditions:

  • the shareholder’s rights have been infringed;
  • the irregularity affected the outcome of the vote;
  • the annulment does not have excessive consequences for the company.

Another new development: failure to comply with the articles of association is no longer sufficient grounds for annulment. In a simplified joint-stock company (SAS), however, the articles of association may provide for this. Finally, the shareholder now has only two years in which to take action.

One issue remains unresolved: to our knowledge, the courts have not yet ruled on how these rules apply where a shareholder has been deprived of their voting rights.

Challenging the sale price

Challenging the price does not call the exclusion into question. If the articles of association do not specify the price and the parties cannot agree, an expert will determine it. The expert is appointed by the court if necessary (Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code).

Key point: Have you received a notice to attend a meeting to vote on your exclusion? Take action before the meeting. Request, in writing, details of the allegations and a deadline for responding. These exchanges will serve as evidence.

Exclusion clause: anticipate rather than react

The exclusion clause should be drawn up when the company is formed, not in the heat of a dispute. If drafted correctly, it can prevent years of litigation. If applied incorrectly, it can backfire on those who invoke it.

Do you wish to expel a partner or challenge your own expulsion? Goldwin Avocats welcomes you at 7 rue Claude Chahu, Paris 16.

Frequently asked questions about the exclusion clause

This is a provision in the articles of association which obliges a shareholder to dispose of their shares in pre-defined circumstances. In the case of a simplified joint-stock company (SAS), Article L. 227-16 of the Commercial Code expressly permits this.
In principle, no. Neither the majority nor the judge has a general power of exclusion. There are other avenues, detailed in our article, for withdrawing from a 50/50 limited liability company. Failure to pay for shares also provides a route. The firm successfully secured a ruling on the transfer of unpaid shares (Nanterre Commercial Court, 12 June 2024). The purchaser lost their status as a partner.
Yes, always. A partner facing expulsion retains the right to vote on their own expulsion. If the articles of association deprive them of this right, that provision is deemed null and void: the court disregards it, as if it did not exist. The remainder of the expulsion clause continues to apply. The Court of Cassation ruled on this on 29 May 2024 (No. 22-13.158). In practical terms, an expulsion voted through without the partner’s participation is contestable. The company may then organise a new vote, with the partner’s participation.
The price is determined in accordance with the method laid down in the articles of association. If the articles of association do not specify a method and the parties cannot agree, an expert shall determine the value. The expert is appointed by the parties or, failing that, by the court (Article 1843-4 of the Civil Code).
The excluded partner may bring an action for annulment before the competent court within two years. They may, for example, cite their absence from the vote or an abuse of majority power. Since 1 October 2025, three conditions must be met for a decision to be set aside. The partner must have suffered a breach of their rights. The irregularity must have affected the outcome of the vote. Finally, setting aside the decision must not have excessive consequences for the company.

Qu'avez-vous pensé de cet article ?

Notez le !

Note moyenne 0 / 5. Nombre de votes 0

Pas encore de votes, soyez le premier à noter cet article

Ask your questions to Goldwin Law Firm
Any questions? Contact our firm
The GOLDWIN firm will contact you as soon as possible. We will only accept your file if we are able to help and support you as best we can with excellence and efficiency.
Any questions? Contact our firm