A retenir
- Definition: a professional appointed by the court temporarily replaces the directors of a company that has ceased to function.
- Conditions: the company is unable to operate, and there is an imminent threat to its interests, supported by evidence.
- Procedure: summary proceedings before the president of the competent court; costs are, in principle, borne by the company.
Your company has ground to a standstill. The partners are no longer on speaking terms. The managing director has gone missing or is blocking everything. No one can sign anything anymore. In this extreme situation, there is a solution: ask the court to appoint a provisional administrator. Here is an overview of their role, the conditions involved, and the cost. A lawyer specialising in disputes between shareholders can help you choose the right course of action.
Is your company paralysed and is no one making decisions anymore?
Goldwin Avocats, in Paris’s 16th arrondissement, will check whether the conditions for appointing a provisional administrator are met.
What is a provisional administrator?
A provisional administrator is a professional appointed by a judge. They temporarily replace the directors of a company that has ground to a halt. They aim to protect the company’s interests whilst the crisis is resolved.
Think of it as an interim pilot. The captain can no longer fly, and the crew is arguing in the cockpit. The judge then puts a neutral pilot at the controls. He does not choose the final destination. However, he keeps the aeroplane airborne until a stable crew returns.
An exceptional measure, created by the courts
There is no legislation defining the provisional administration of commercial or civil companies. It is a concept developed through case law. Judges, therefore, reserve it for serious crises, as it strips power from the current management. In principle, the judge appoints an insolvency practitioner registered on the national list (Article L. 811-2 of the Commercial Code). The judge may also appoint a qualified individual, such as a chartered accountant, provided they can justify this choice.
Provisional administrator or ad hoc agent: do not confuse the two.
These two measures are often confused. However, they differ significantly in scope. An ad hoc representative is given a one-off task, such as convening a general meeting. A provisional administrator, on the other hand, takes over the management of the company. The Court of Cassation has reiterated that the appointment of an ad hoc agent does not require proof of imminent danger (Cass. com., 21 Sept. 2022, No. 20-21.416).
| Criteria | Ad hoc representative | Provisional administrator |
|---|---|---|
| Role | Specific and limited in scope | Full or partial management |
| Senior management | Remain in post | Removed from the management of the entrusted operations |
| Terms | More flexible | Paralysis and imminent danger |
| Example | Convening a deadlocked meeting | Managing an SCI without a manager |
For example, Goldwin Avocats secured the appointment of an agent in a case where an SCI manager refused to convene the general meeting. A minor measure was sufficient.
Key point: requesting a provisional administrator when an ad hoc representative would suffice risks rejection. Choosing the right measure is your first strategic decision.
What are the conditions for obtaining a provisional administrator?
The court requires two cumulative conditions to be met. Firstly, the company must be unable to operate normally. Secondly, there must be an imminent threat to the company’s interests. A mere disagreement between shareholders is therefore not sufficient.
Paralysis of the governing bodies and imminent danger
The first condition relates to paralysis. For example, no general meeting is able to pass any resolution whatsoever. The second condition relates to urgency. The danger must be imminent and real: loss of an asset, suspension of payments or misappropriation of funds.
Furthermore, the Court of Cassation emphasises the company’s interests. The applicant must act to protect the company, not their personal interests (Cass. com., 22 Jan. 2025, No. 22-20.526). Thus, a partner who is merely seeking to settle a personal score with the manager will have their claim dismissed.
Finally, the company’s recovery must remain a possibility. If it has no future, the judge will prefer its dissolution to provisional administration.
What is sufficient? What is not sufficient?
| Situation | Is an appointment possible? |
|---|---|
| Death or disappearance of the sole director, with no replacement | Yes, if the company is at risk |
| Partners with equal shares unable to vote on any matter | Yes, if the deadlock puts the company at risk |
| A director who is draining the company of its assets | Yes, depending on the evidence provided |
| Disagreement, but the company is still operating | No |
| Challenge to the validity of a general meeting | No, other remedies are available |
| Financial difficulties without paralysis of the governing bodies | No |
Do you hold half the shares and find everything at a standstill? First, find out how to exit a limited liability company (SARL) with 50/50 ownership. Does a resolution seem irregular to you? In that case, it is better to challenge the decision of the general meeting.
Point to note: the judge hearing the application for interim relief cannot remove the manager of a civil company. However, they may appoint a provisional administrator if an imminent threat is proven (Court of Cassation, 3rd Civil Chamber, 7 May 2026, No. 24-12.164). The removal of the director follows a different procedure.
The case of family-owned property investment companies (SCIs)
SCIs account for a large proportion of such disputes. Shares are often held equally, within a family or inheritance context. Nevertheless, the court remains strict. A dispute, even a very serious one, is not sufficient grounds unless it paralyses the company. Similarly, irregular notices of meetings or a failure to provide accounts are not always sufficient grounds.
On the other hand, a manager who consistently withholds all information from their partners may expose the company to imminent danger. Starting with a less severe measure, such as appointing an ad hoc representative, will strengthen your case should that measure prove unsuccessful.
Are you unsure which course of action to take? The lawyers at Goldwin Avocats, in Paris’s 16th arrondissement, will analyse your case and identify the safest course of action. Tell us about your situation.
What evidence should you gather before taking the matter to court?
The judge rules on the basis of the evidence submitted. You must prove, with supporting documents, that the company is no longer functioning and that it faces a real threat. A list of grievances without evidence will lead to the case being dismissed.
In practice, the most useful documents are:
- summonses that have gone unanswered and minutes of meetings that were blocked;
- written correspondence showing a refusal to make decisions;
- bank statements, overdrafts and formal notices from creditors;
- financial statements that have not been approved or filed;
- evidence of acts contrary to the company’s interests;
- the report of an ad hoc representative whose mandate has failed.
Each piece of evidence must link the deadlock to a risk to the company, rather than solely to your own loss.
How does the appointment procedure work?
The application is usually made by way of summary proceedings before the president of the competent court. The applicant must prove that the company is paralysed and that there is a risk. The judge then issues an order setting out the terms of the mandate, its duration and the remuneration.
Who can apply to the judge?
Any person demonstrating a legitimate interest may bring the application. In practice, this includes:
- a partner or shareholder, even a minority one;
- a director or a corporate body;
- the auditor;
- the Social and Economic Committee (CSE);
- the public prosecutor’s office.
However, an employee acting in their capacity as a mere employee cannot bring proceedings. Nor can a creditor of the company: the Court of Cassation has ruled on this (Cass. com., 7 May 2025, No. 23-20.471).
Which court should the matter be brought before?
| Type of company | Competent court |
|---|---|
| Commercial company (SARL, SAS, SA) | President of the Commercial Court or the Economic Activities Court |
| Civil company (SCI, SCP) or association | President of the District Court |
In Paris, the Commercial Court is now known as the Economic Activities Court. This pilot scheme covers twelve courts, from 1 January 2025 to 31 December 2028.
Interim relief remains the main procedure (Articles 872–873 or 834–835 of the Code of Civil Procedure). An application without an adversarial hearing remains exceptional. The company may subsequently apply for its withdrawal. If the judge rules in its favour, the appointment is revoked.
What the order stipulates
- the identity of the provisional administrator;
- the exact scope of their remit;
- the duration of the appointment, which in practice is often six months, renewable;
- their remuneration and the advance payment to be made.
The appointment is then published in the Trade and Companies Register, in a legal gazette and in the BODACC.
What does the provisional administrator actually do?
They exercise the powers entrusted to them by the judge, no more and no less. Their remit ranges from simple supervision to full management. For any dispositive act, such as selling an asset, they must obtain the judge’s authorisation.
The judge chooses between three levels of intervention:
- Supervision: the judge monitors the management without replacing the directors.
- Specific task: they carry out a specific task, such as convening a meeting of the partners.
- Full management: the judge exercises the powers of the director in their place.
Let’s take a hypothetical example. The manager of SCI Les Tilleuls passes away. His brother and his heirs cannot agree on a successor. Rent is no longer coming in, and the bank is threatening action. The provisional administrator collects the rent, pays off the loan, and then convenes the partners to elect a manager. The firm has, in fact, secured the appointment of a provisional administrator for an SCI without a manager.
Where the court order confers upon him all the functions of the manager, he may carry out all management acts alone. The directors are not dismissed: they remain in office, but their powers are suspended. However, the administrator cannot take decisions reserved for the shareholders, such as the winding-up of the company.
Key point: the provisional administrator is neither a partner’s lawyer nor an arbitrator. He acts on behalf of the company. Do not rely on him to settle your dispute.
How much does a provisional administrator cost?
The judge sets the remuneration, which is, in principle, payable by the company. An advance payment is often requested from the applicant at the outset. There is no public scale of fees: the amount depends on the duration and complexity of the assignment.
Remuneration is generally calculated on an hourly rate. We do not have any reliable, recent figures on the average cost. Furthermore, the judge may order that these costs be borne by a director at fault. They may also be charged to the shareholder responsible for the crisis.
Point to note: the advance payment can place a heavy financial burden on the partner bringing the claim. Plan for this cash outlay before initiating proceedings.
Before taking any action, have your strategy assessed. Consulting a lawyer specialising in disputes between partners will enable you to gauge the costs, timeframes and chances of success.
How does the administration come to an end?
The appointment ends on the date set by the judge or as soon as the crisis is resolved. A new director, an agreement between partners, a sale, dissolution, or insolvency proceedings: each outcome brings the provisional administration to an end.
What if the crisis persists? The provisional administrator buys time but does not resolve the underlying issues. It will then be necessary to pursue mediation and conflict resolution between the partners, or to consider judicial dissolution due to a breakdown in relations. If the partners agree to wind up the company, an amicable liquidation remains an option.
Is your company at a standstill and time is running out? Goldwin Avocats, a business law firm in Paris’s 16th arrondissement, helps you act swiftly and take the right steps. Contact the firm.
Can a provisional administrator unblock your company? Goldwin Avocats will analyse your articles of association, your evidence and the urgency of the situation to determine the appropriate course of action. Book an appointment for an initial confidential discussion.
Sources (accessed on 18 November 2026)
Frequently asked questions about the provisional administrator